The world of commercial real estate is intricate and diverse, especially when comparing leasing practices between different countries. For students and early professionals considering a transatlantic adventure, understanding these differences is key. Today, we’ll journey across the Atlantic and delve into the five major distinctions between US and UK commercial leases.
1. Lease Length & Flexibility
US: Emphasis on Short-Term Flexibility
In the ever-changing landscape of US commercial real estate, leases are designed to accommodate flux. They usually span between 3 to 10 years, relatively short in comparison to that of the UK. This is beneficial for growing businesses that are unsure of their long-term space needs. In the office sector, co-working companies have taken this to an extreme, offering office space on a monthly basis.
In contrast, more well established enterprises seeking stability can still opt for extended lease durations, coupled with options to renew the lease at the end of the initial lease term.
UK: The Stability of Long-Term Agreements
Historically, UK commercial leases had impressive lengths, often ranging from 15 to 25 years. This practice has roots in tradition, emphasizing stability and long-term business commitments. However, the modern era has seen a shift towards more flexibility, with terms often around 10 years.
For a new restaurant chain establishing its flagship location in the heart of London, a longer lease might be ideal. It secures their spot and ensures they won’t be priced out if the location becomes the next big dining hub.
Although long-term leases can provide security for growing companies, they can also present challenges in periods of changing market dynamics. Consider the case of Debenhams. Founded in the 18th century, Debenhams was a fixture on many UK high streets and shopping centres. Over the years, it entered into long-term leases for expansive spaces in prime locations. As consumer habits shifted towards online shopping platforms like ASOS and as competition from other high street brands intensified, Debenhams began to struggle. Their long-term lease commitments made it cumbersome for them to downsize or relocate. This inflexibility made it challenging to adapt their business model swiftly.
2. Rent Increases
US: Simplicity Is Key
In the US, the principle of “what you see is what you get” often applies. Commercial leases tend to have fixed rents, which are either constant throughout the term or have predefined annual increases. These increases might be tied to indicators like the Consumer Price Index (CPI). For example, a budding art gallery in New York might strike a deal at $20,000 per month, increasing by 3% annually to account for inflation. In more complex leases, rent bumps can include a cap and a collar, meaning that there is a predefined floor and ceiling for how much rent can increase per annum.
UK: A Dance of Regular Adjustments
The UK’s approach to rent increases (known as “rent reviews”) can be more intricate. It’s common to find “upward-only” rent reviews scheduled every 5 years. This clause ensures that rents don’t go down – even if market rents decrease. The reviews often reflect the open market rental value. So, our Oxford Street fashion retailer in London, starting at £200,000 per year, might face a sudden rent hike if the area has an upswing in demand. However, if there’s a market dip, they won’t enjoy a rent reduction.
Although this may seem like a good bargain for the landlord, in time of high inflation (like we are seeing now), landlords are unable to increase rents in line with inflation and can see their rental streams remain static even if their debt payments increase due to higher interest rates.
3. Lease Structure
US: The Triple Net Lease Approach
One common lease structure in the US is the “triple net lease” or NNN lease. This lease structure means that the tenant bears the brunt of three major expenses: property taxes, insurance, and property maintenance, but in return pays a lower “net rent” that factors in these expenses. These types of lease terms tend to be longer, often 10 years or longer. They are also most common for single-tenant buildings, where one tenant occupies 100% of the space.
UK: Navigating Full Repairing and Insuring Leases
The UK’s answer to the NNN lease is the Full Repairing and Insuring (FRI) lease. Tenants are typically responsible for all repairs and must insure the premises. However, there’s a twist: unlike in the US, where landlords can directly pass costs onto tenants, UK tenants often negotiate ceilings on these costs or “outgoings”. So, our pottery studio in Edinburgh might agree to contribute towards a new roof but will ensure that there’s a cap on their liability.
4. Break Clauses
US: Varied Options
Break clauses in US commercial leases are as diverse as the country itself. These clauses can be tailored to cater to either party’s specific needs. A software company in Austin, wary of market unpredictability, might negotiate a break clause allowing them to break the lease if their product fails to hit sales targets within two years, provided they give ample notice. On the contrary, a landlord might negotiate a break clause in two years if they are able to obtain planning permission to develop on their property.
UK: Tenant-Focused Termination
In the UK, break clauses traditionally lean towards tenant benefits. These provisions, negotiated upfront, often occur at the midpoint of the lease term. A Manchester-based restaurant with a 10-year lease might have a break at year five, allowing them to re-evaluate their position. However, it’s imperative to meet all conditions, like proper notice. Otherwise, the clause could be voided.
Additionally, tenants in the UK are afforded additional protections due to the Landlord and Tenant Act of 1954, a pivotal UK legislation that primarily safeguards business tenants by granting them security of tenure. This means that tenants have the right to remain in their premises and request a lease renewal upon its conclusion.
While tenants can renew, landlords have limited, specific grounds to oppose such renewals, like the need for property redevelopment. If landlords oppose on certain grounds, tenants might be entitled to compensation. The Act also establishes clear notice provisions and procedures for both parties, ensuring transparency in intentions regarding lease continuation or termination.
5. Legal Framework and Protection
US: The Diversity of State Laws
In the US, commercial lease regulations vary considerably from state to state. Some states, like California, offer tenants protection against sudden rent spikes or unjust evictions. However, overarching federal protections are missing, making local laws paramount.
UK: The Shield of Statutory Rights
The UK has long championed tenant rights. Acts like the Landlord and Tenant Act of 1954 bolster security of tenure. This provides a safety net; at lease end, a tenant can typically renew. The landlord’s refusal is limited to specific conditions. Think of a heritage bakery in Birmingham – after decades of in business, they can rest easy, knowing that the law provides them a robust position to negotiate a lease renewal.
There’s no “one-size-fits-all” in commercial leasing, especially when comparing two different jurisdictions like the US and UK. But it’s useful to know the various common practices and lease structures. Whether you are working across geographies or doing deals in a single location, it’s useful to have some perspective on commercial leases
Thanks for reading!
Getting value from our free materials? Consider supporting us on Patreon